The 5 Best Bakeries Around Steubenville

For many, the smell of fresh-baked goods—whether it's sweet cinnamon rolls or warm artisan bread—is the ultimate definition of comfort. Bakeries are truly a foundational pillar of community, blending culinary artistry with tradition. Since the earliest bakers' guild was established in Rome around 168 BC, the demand for high-quality baked products has persisted, and today, an estimated $311 billion is generated annually by the US baking industry alone. Our annual Steubenville Best of the Best readers' choice contest asked the local community to share where they go for the best cakes, cookies, pastries, and doughnuts, celebrating the local shops that rise above the rest.

Gus's Goodies

Celebrating 90 years in business, Gus's Goodies is a pillar of the Weirton community, specializing in local baking at its finest. They offer a wide array of baked goods, including specialty cakes, cookies, and doughnuts, perfect for any occasion. Their decorated cakes are known for their meticulously sculpted icing designs—with no artificial add-ons—and they offer popular flavors like white, chocolate, red velvet, and carrot, alongside fillings such as raspberry, lemon, and peanut butter. The bakery requests a 48-hour advance notice for all orders, demonstrating their commitment to quality and freshness.

Downtown Bakery

Since 1958, Downtown Bakery has become the gold standard for baking in Steubenville, OH. This local, family-owned business prides itself on offering a massive selection of affordably priced, freshly baked treats, living up to its motto: "You can taste the difference." Customers can choose from a full menu of items ranging from bread (like Italian and Jewish Egg Bread) and pies to an extensive selection of cookies and doughnuts. Signature items that keep people coming back include their famous smiley face cookies, cream horns, and Devil Dog pastries.

Sweet Temptations Pastry Shop

Located in Weirton, Sweet Temptations Pastry Shop is a delightful haven known for its array of beautifully crafted sweet treats and comforting savory options. The shop specializes in custom cakes and decadent desserts, with popular items including signature cinnamon rolls and rich cheesecakes. They pride themselves on a meticulous balance of quality ingredients and artistry, with staff known for their passion and dedication. The bakery provides specialty cakes and desserts, with custom cake consultations available by appointment only.

Kitch’s Kitchen

Kitch's Kitchen in Toronto, OH, has successfully transitioned from a home-based business to a full-time, brick-and-mortar bakery. Owned by Sarah Phillips, the bakery offers an assortment of fresh bread, doughnuts, and gourmet sweets. Display cases are filled with favorites like gourmet cupcakes and specialty doughnuts, with highly popular flavors including pineapple upside down and cherry cheesecake cupcakes, and lemon blueberry doughnuts. Beyond the baked goods, Kitch's Kitchen also offers a savory menu that includes wraps, salads, and traditional breakfast items.

Rustik Rollz

Rustik Rollz, based in Weirton, WV, is recognized for its commitment to high-quality, specialty baked items. While operating primarily from a designated office and production space, this business has built a reputation for its unique offerings within the local market. The company is registered in Hancock County and emphasizes a strong focus on retail trade, connecting directly with customers to provide their distinctive baked goods.

Whether you’re in the mood for a nostalgic doughnut, a beautifully custom-made cake for a special event, or a perfect loaf of fresh bread, the Steubenville area is fortunate to have these five exceptional bakeries. They maintain the tradition of baking excellence that brings warmth and sweetness to the community every day.

Thanks, Gemini.