The 5 Best Cakes Around Steubenville

From celebratory sheet cakes to exquisite European-style tortes and local regional specialties, the Steubenville area is a haven for cake lovers. The "Best of the Best 2025" selections for cakes highlight the premier bakeries known for their rich flavors, creative designs, and commitment to fresh, homemade quality. Whether you're planning a wedding, a birthday, or simply seeking a sweet indulgence, these five shops are baking the most delicious and memorable cakes in the region.

Gus's Goodies

Gus's Goodies earns its top distinction by offering a vast menu of traditional, homestyle cakes and classic bakery items, specializing in both large-scale sheet cakes and regional favorites. Among their most popular offerings are the Famous Chiffon Cakes, which are highly regarded for their light, airy texture, and the rich, decadent Burnt Almond Torte. Beyond standard layer cakes, Gus's is also celebrated for its seasonal specialties, including the ever-popular Pumpkin Roll and the wide variety of large, customizable sheet cakes perfect for any occasion in classic flavors like Red Velvet, Marble, or Chocolate.

A Touch Of Elegance Bakery & Cafe

A Touch of Elegance Bakery & Cafe is the premier choice for custom-designed cakes and French-inspired desserts, catering to patrons looking for a beautiful and sophisticated treat. This bakery is best known for its signature Fruit Explosion Cake, a creation that combines light cake layers with fresh fruit and a creamy filling, living up to its name with bright, fresh flavors. In addition to custom 6-inch, 8-inch, and 10-inch cakes perfect for celebrations, the bakery specializes in gourmet European pastries like Macarons (in flavors like Raspberry Chocolate and Peanut Butter Bliss) and other meticulously crafted items, ensuring every slice is as elegant as it is delicious.

Sweet Temptations Pastry Shop

Sweet Temptations Pastry Shop stands out for its extensive variety of scratch-made layered cakes and single-serving desserts, having won local accolades for its quality and customer service. They offer an impressive selection of cake slices and small-layer cakes in creative and classic combinations, with favorites including Red Velvet with cream cheese icing, Lemon Lemon cake, and various fruit-filled options like Strawberry Shortcake and Pineapple Cake. The shop is also known for its rich Pound Cakes and decadent single-serving Cheesecakes, all made fresh daily with a dedication to old-fashioned baking excellence.

Cake Roll Creations

Cake Roll Creations carves out a niche in the Steubenville area by mastering the elegant and delicate art of the Cake Roll (or Swiss roll). This specialized baker offers numerous flavors of moist sponge cake tightly rolled around a rich filling, moving far beyond the simple jelly roll to create sophisticated desserts. While flavors rotate seasonally, popular specialties include the autumn Pumpkin Roll with a creamy filling, the refreshing Strawberry Roll Cake, and the indulgent Chocolate Cake Roll, making them the top choice for this unique, visually stunning, and portion-friendly style of cake.

Downtown Bakery

Downtown Bakery is a beloved, long-established full-service bakery known for its traditional, reliable, and generously-sized cakes perfect for family gatherings and celebrations. This classic shop excels in familiar favorites, including its signature Chocolate Rolls (often filled with whipped buttercream), its decadent German Chocolate Cakes (featuring a sweet coconut-pecan filling), and custom layer cakes available in various sheet sizes. They also offer dessert-style options like Cheesecake and Angel Food Cake, all crafted daily using recipes that have made them a local institution for over 65 years.

Thanks, Gemini.