The 5 Best Convenience Stores Around Steubenville

In the fast-paced life of the Ohio Valley, a great convenience store is more than just a place to grab gas and a quick drink—it's a vital community hub for fresh meals, local staples, and friendly service. The "Best of the Best 2025" list celebrates the stores that excel at providing speed, quality, and a unique local touch. From family-owned delis that honor tradition to modern fueling stations that offer a full dining experience, these five spots truly define convenience around Steubenville.

Sheetz

Sheetz stands as the undisputed champion of modern convenience and customized food service. Customers love the 24/7 Made-To-Order (MTO) menu, which allows you to build everything from specialty sandwiches and burritos to customized coffee drinks on demand via digital kiosks. Beyond the freshly prepared food, Sheetz offers clean restrooms, well-lit fueling stations, and a wide variety of snacks and beverages, making it the perfect one-stop shop for travelers and local commuters alike.

Federico Foods

Federico Foods is less a convenience store and more a beloved, fourth-generation family-owned Italian market and deli that happens to be conveniently located. Locals flock here for the authentic Italian experience, which includes a deli counter featuring high-quality imported meats and cheeses, homemade baked goods, and specialty items you simply can't find elsewhere. Their famous Italian hoagies and subs, made on freshly baked bread, are legendary. Federico Foods proves that true convenience sometimes means quick access to gourmet, tradition-rich food.

Mark's Carry Out

Mark's Carry Out earns its high marks by focusing on the fundamentals of a local convenience store: speed, essentials, and friendly, quick service. It's the dependable neighborhood stop for everyday needs, including basic groceries, popular domestic beers, and tobacco products, often offering competitive pricing. Mark's caters directly to local residents who appreciate the drive-up window convenience, allowing them to grab necessary items without ever leaving their car—a significant time saver for busy locals.

Natalie’s Nook

Natalie’s Nook has built its reputation on being an exceptional local spot for fresh, prepared meals and catering that goes far beyond typical convenience store fare. While serving standard grab-and-go items, the "Nook" focuses on providing high-quality, comforting food options that feel homemade. It’s the perfect place for a delicious and quick lunch, catering to those who want a quality meal without the time commitment of a sit-down restaurant. Its local popularity is a testament to the value placed on fresh, local food that’s easy to access.

K & J's Skip N Go

K & J's Skip N Go is celebrated as a classic, reliable neighborhood store that acts as an anchor for the Follansbee community. Customers appreciate the no-fuss, familiar environment and personalized service. This store provides the essentials: gas, snacks, drinks, and lottery—all delivered with the kind of personal touch that only a truly local, independent business can offer. For a quick stop and a friendly face, K & J's is the community's trusted "go-to" for skipping the stress and getting what you need fast.

Thanks, Gemini.