The 5 Best Cookies Around Steubenville

Whether you’re craving a classic chocolate chip, a buttery thumbprint, or a beautifully decorated sugar cookie, the Steubenville area is brimming with sweet spots that deliver. These five bakeries and pastry shops are local legends for a reason—each one offering irresistible treats made with care, creativity, and plenty of flavor. If you’ve got a sweet tooth (or need the perfect box of cookies for your next gathering), make it a point to visit these Best of the Best 2025 winners.

Gus’s Goodies

It’s no surprise that Gus’s Goodies continues to be a local favorite. With a legacy that spans generations, this Weirton gem is best known for its expansive cookie selection—think chocolate chip, peanut butter, spritz, kiffles, and perfectly decorated seasonal cutouts. Every bite is fresh, flavorful, and baked from scratch. Whether you're stopping in for a few or placing a tray order for a party, Gus’s delivers cookies that are both nostalgic and unforgettable.

Downtown Bakery

In the heart of Steubenville, Downtown Bakery has been serving up cookie perfection for decades. Their display cases are always stocked with golden classics—soft sugar cookies, chocolate-dipped delights, and crisp varieties that melt in your mouth. Family-owned and deeply rooted in tradition, this bakery is beloved not only for its cookies but also for the welcoming vibe that makes every visit feel like home. If you haven’t made Downtown Bakery part of your weekly routine yet, now’s the time.

Sweet Temptations Pastry Shop

For cookies that are as stunning as they are scrumptious, Sweet Temptations Pastry Shop in Weirton is your go-to. Known for their hand-decorated sugar cookies and themed assortments, this shop specializes in custom designs that are almost too pretty to eat—almost. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, holiday, or just another Tuesday, their cookies bring beauty and taste together in perfect harmony.

Fat Apple Bakery

Bridgeport’s Fat Apple Bakery is where flavor meets indulgence. Their cookie game is strong, with rich, chewy varieties like oatmeal raisin, double chocolate, and other rotating seasonal options. Every batch is made from scratch with high-quality ingredients, and it shows. Whether you're grabbing a dozen for your office or sneaking one for yourself, Fat Apple’s cookies are a delicious way to brighten any day.

Kitch’s Kitchen

Tucked away in Toronto, Kitch’s Kitchen is a hidden gem baking up some of the most delightful cookies in the Ohio Valley. From butter-rich classics to inventive flavor combos, each cookie has that fresh-from-the-oven taste that keeps locals coming back. Their charming presentation and warm customer service make it the kind of place where you walk in for one treat and leave with a whole box.

From iconic neighborhood bakeries to creative cookie artisans, these five businesses prove that Steubenville is a sweet spot for dessert lovers. If you haven’t tried them yet, consider this your sign—treat yourself today to one (or five) of the best cookies around.

Thanks, ChatGPT!