The 5 Best Fish Sandwiches Around Steubenville

A great fish sandwich strikes a balance: crisp exterior, tender fillet, and a bun that holds its ground. In the Steubenville–Weirton area, that balance shows up at longtime counters and market stalls where lunch moves fast and the fryer stays busy. Whether you favor hand-filleted tradition or a classic take you can count on any day of the week, these spots deliver the kind of sandwich that makes a detour worth it.

Steve’s Fish & Chips

A local staple for decades, Steve’s Fish & Chips focuses on familiar comforts done right. The fish sandwich leads the lineup—golden, straightforward, and sized for a proper lunch—backed by sides that keep the meal simple. Regulars watch the feed for day-to-day updates and specials, then call ahead to keep pickup quick.

Colemans Fish Market

Inside Wheeling’s Centre Market, Coleman’s has built a legend around its hand-filleted fish sandwiches. The draw is consistency: fresh fish, a generous cut, and a clean fry that keeps the flavor front and center. Order at the counter, add a cup of chowder if you’re hungry, and understand why this sandwich is a regional rite of passage.

Mark’s Carry Out

Known for a busy deli and hot case, Mark’s also leans into fried-fish Fridays and an easy-to-like sandwich lineup. It’s a practical choice when you’re feeding a few people: grab subs for the sandwich crowd, add a round of fish sandwiches for the classicists, and get back to the office before the break disappears.

Def Louie’s Sandwich Shop

Def Louie’s reads like a greatest-hits board for cravings, and the fish sandwich slots right in. The shop posts rotating features and pop-ups, so fans keep an eye on updates before rolling through. Expect a hearty build and the kind of side options—fries, chips, or a cup of soup—that turn a quick stop into a full meal.

White Bear

An old-school roadside favorite, White Bear pairs easygoing service with plates that feel like a small-town diner should. The fish sandwich hits that comfort sweet spot—crisp, warm, and ready to carry you through the afternoon. If you’re making it a full sit-down, add a classic side and call it a day well spent.

Thanks, ChatGPT.