The 5 Best Ice Cream Shops Around Steubenville

Nothing resets a day like a good scoop. In the Weirton Daily Times Best of the Best 2025 Readers’ Choice Awards for the Steubenville area, locals pointed to spots where cones, shakes, and sundaes come with friendly counters and small-town charm. From soft-serve classics to bookstores with a sweet side, these five favorites make dessert worth the detour.

Howdy’s Dari Owl

A Follansbee fixture for generations, Howdy’s serves the kind of soft-serve that draws families all season. Think swirl cones, sundaes with plenty of toppings, and a simple, fast-moving line that gets you back outside before the sprinkles settle. It’s the definition of a neighborhood ice cream stop.

Mar-Ta-Lee Dairy Bar

A country drive with a sweet payoff, Mar-Ta-Lee pairs nostalgia with generous portions. The menu covers cones, shakes, and flurries, with rotating flavors and old-school favorites that feel just right after a ball game or a Sunday drive.

PRIME at the Weirton Book Company

Books and ice cream share the same address here, which means a relaxed browse can end with a cone or a shake. Families love the flavor variety and the cozy vibe, and it’s an easy place to meet friends when some want a new read and others want dessert.

Ice Cream Island, LLC

Cadiz’s Ice Cream Island keeps the case busy with hard-serve flavors, thick shakes, and crowd-pleasing specials. The shop posts updates for limited items and seasonal twists, so regulars know when to swing by for something new.

The Twister Restaurant & Ice Cream Shoppe

Part diner, part dessert destination, Twister pairs classic meals with soft-serve and hard-serve scoops. It’s a practical stop when the table wants more than cones—finish dinner, then order sundaes without changing venues.

Thanks, ChatGPT.