The 5 Best Insurance Agencies Around Steubenville

The right agency does more than write a policy. It explains coverage in plain English, answers the phone when you need help, and checks in as life changes. In the Weirton Daily Times Best of the Best 2025 Readers’ Choice Awards for the Steubenville area, locals highlighted offices that pair expertise with follow-through. If you’re comparing quotes, service, and long-term support, start with these five.

Casie Johnson State Farm Insurance Agency

A Wintersville favorite for personal lines, Casie Johnson’s office helps families sort auto, home, renters, life, and small-business coverage with clear guidance on limits and discounts. The team’s emphasis on accessibility—call, text, or stop by—makes it easy to update policies as milestones stack up.

Drexler Insurance

As an independent agency in Follansbee, Drexler shops multiple carriers to tailor auto, home, and commercial packages. Homeowners appreciate the practical approach: review risks, compare options, and bundle where it makes sense. Quick service links and quote tools keep the process moving.

Toni Moreland State Farm

Born-and-raised local insight meets a full State Farm lineup at Toni Moreland’s Toronto office. From first apartments to new homes and growing families, the team maps coverage to real budgets and follows up with the small adjustments—beneficiary updates, endorsements—that matter later.

Jack Fowler State Farm

Weirton’s Jack Fowler office blends a neighborhood feel with broad product depth. Whether you’re reviewing deductibles, adding a teen driver, or asking about business or specialty coverage, the staff lays out choices side by side so decisions come easier.

Taylor Insurance & Financial Services, LLC

Steubenville’s Taylor Insurance works as an independent advocate for clients, comparing policies across carriers and coordinating personal and commercial coverage. The value is in the guidance: straightforward quotes, responsive service, and help aligning premiums and protection with your priorities.

Thanks, ChatGPT.