The 5 Best Insurance Agents Around Steubenville

The right agent feels like a translator and an advocate—someone who makes sense of deductibles and endorsements, then shows up when you need a claim handled fast. In the Weirton Daily Times Best of the Best 2025 Readers Choice Awards for the Steubenville area, locals pointed to professionals who combine plain-English guidance with prompt service. If you’re comparing quotes, coverage, and follow-through, start with these five.

Casie Johnson – State Farm

Known for accessibility and clear explanations, Casie Johnson’s Wintersville office helps families map auto, home, renters, and life coverage to real budgets. The agency lays out contact options, office hours, and digital tools upfront, making it easy to get a quote, tweak limits, or ask questions as life changes.

Dave McDonald – Drexler Insurance, LLC

As an independent agent, Dave McDonald shops multiple carriers to build policies that fit the household or business rather than the other way around. The Drexler site spells out personal and commercial options and offers quick quote pathways, so you can compare rates and coverages without bouncing across a dozen tabs.

Jack Fowler – State Farm

A Weirton mainstay, Jack Fowler pairs a neighborhood feel with the breadth of a national carrier. Whether you’re adding a teen driver, reviewing homeowners limits, or exploring life insurance, the office organizes choices side by side and handles the follow-up that keeps policies aligned with your plans.

Taylor Steeves – Taylor Insurance & Financial Services, LLC

Taylor Steeves runs an independent shop that streamlines quotes across insurers for auto, home, life, and small-business needs. With a local office in Steubenville and straightforward online contact forms, the agency focuses on responsive communication and practical options tailored to each stage of life.

Michael Lytle – Joyia Lytle: Allstate Insurance

Part of the Joyia Lytle Allstate team in Weirton, Michael Lytle helps clients weigh deductibles, discounts, and bundling strategies, then keeps in touch when vehicles, homes, or families change. The agency’s page makes it simple to start a quote or book time to review coverages face to face.

Thanks, ChatGPT.