The 5 Best Mexican Restaurants Around Steubenville

The results are in! The taste buds of the Ohio Valley have spoken, crowning the winners of The Weirton Daily Times Best of the Best 2025 Readers Choice Awards for the Steubenville area. This prestigious annual contest highlights the top dining establishments in the region, and the Mexican food category was, as always, hotly contested.

From authentic street tacos to modern, creative dishes, the five winning restaurants have captivated the community with their vibrant flavors, welcoming service, and commitment to quality. These establishments represent the gold standard of Mexican cuisine as voted by the local readers.

Here are the five champions:

Chico Fiesta Mexican Grill

Chico Fiesta Mexican Grill is a consistent winner, celebrated for providing a classic, festive Mexican dining experience. Diners flock here for the traditional dishes, but the fresh ingredients are what truly sets them apart. They offer an extensive menu featuring savory enchiladas, hearty burritos, and a full bar. Whether you're in the mood for sizzling Fajitas or a delicious specialty like the Chico Chicken, this spot promises large portions and a family-friendly atmosphere.

Crazy Mexican Restaurant & Grill

This restaurant lives up to its name by offering an exciting and eclectic menu that goes beyond the ordinary. Crazy Mexican Restaurant & Grill is particularly famous for its unique tableside preparations, especially their Chunky Guacamole, which is a must-try appetizer. Popular menu items include the Crazy Piña (a grilled pineapple fajita dish) and a wide array of seafood and steak options. Known for its strong cocktail menu and lively atmosphere, it’s a go-to for a fun night out.

Puerto Vallarta Restaurant

Puerto Vallarta is a local pillar of authentic Mexican tradition. This restaurant is dedicated to serving classic Mexican recipes in a warm and inviting setting. The menu is robust, covering all the staples you expect—from chimichangas and flautas to combination plates—ensuring there is something for every palate. The Steubenville location maintains a loyal following thanks to its consistent food quality and service, making it a reliable choice for genuine Mexican cuisine.

3 Bad Hombres Margarita Bar & Grill

If you're looking for a modern mashup of flavors paired with top-tier cocktails, 3 Bad Hombres is the place. This restaurant successfully blends traditional Mexican fare with contemporary food trends, offering innovative items alongside classic dishes. Patrons rave about the flavorful Birria Tacos and the rich, melted cheese dishes like Choriqueso. As a "Margarita Bar & Grill," their drink menu is a major draw, featuring creative cocktails and the highly recommended Margarita Flights.

4th Street Standard

A true standout for its innovative approach, 4th Street Standard offers a fully customizable and modern Mexican street food experience. The menu centers around Build-Your-Own bowls, burritos, and tacos, allowing for countless combinations of fresh proteins and house-made toppings. For adventurous diners, unique items like the savory Birria Ramen and the indulgent Birria Grilled Cheese showcase the restaurant's culinary creativity. With its focus on fresh ingredients and bold, unique flavors, it’s a popular spot for a quick, high-quality, and satisfying meal.

Thanks, Gemini!