The 5 Best Overall Restaurants Around Steubenville

The votes are in from the community, and these five establishments have been recognized for offering the finest dining experiences, food quality, and service in the Ohio Valley. The contest name, the Best of the Best Reader's Choice Awards, confirms these restaurants are the community's favorites for 2025.

Pastaio Cucina Rustica Italiana

As a consistent top winner in the Reader's Choice Awards, Pastaio Cucina Rustica Italiana is celebrated for its commitment to authentic, rustic Italian cuisine. Patrons rave about the house-made pastas and signature dishes like the linguine alla calabrese. The restaurant provides a warm, contemporary dining atmosphere that makes it a local favorite for both special occasions and a great weeknight meal.

Murrays' Restaurant

Murrays' Restaurant is a long-standing local staple, renowned for its diverse menu that caters to all tastes, especially its comforting, homestyle cooking. The restaurant offers a wide array of options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with popular dinner items including the hearty country fried steak, flaky fried cod fish, and their hot beef and gravy sandwich. Known for its generous portions and friendly, hometown service, Murrays' provides a welcoming and reliable dining experience for the whole family.

Theo Yianni's

Theo Yianni's Authentic Greek American Cuisine has earned a top spot for its unique blend of traditional Greek flavors and classic American dishes. The menu features standout items like flaming saganaki (Greek cheese), gyro platters, and popular wraps and sandwiches. Reviewers consistently praise the restaurant for its friendly service, cozy atmosphere, and commitment to fresh ingredients, making it a vibrant destination for a casual and satisfying meal.

Naples Spaghetti House

A cherished institution in Steubenville since 1923, Naples Spaghetti House is a culinary landmark known for its authentic, old-world Italian cuisine. This classic eatery is famous for its generous portions of pasta dishes, homemade sauces, and favorites like the cheese ravioli and hearty sandwiches. The restaurant provides a traditional, family-friendly atmosphere, ensuring a comforting and memorable dining experience with every visit.

White Bear

Johnson's White Bear Inn, affectionately known as White Bear, is a beloved rural destination famous for its massive sandwiches and excellent fish dishes. This establishment is praised by the community for its generous portions, great value, and warm hospitality. It's a classic American restaurant experience that draws crowds for its consistently delicious food, making it a reliable choice for a hearty meal in a friendly setting.

Thanks, Gemini.