The 5 Best Pizza Places Around Steubenville

In the Ohio Valley, a slice of pizza can tell a story about local food traditions. While some diners prefer a thin, crisp crust topped with pepperoni, others seek thick, chewy dough, specialty combinations or the region's distinctive approach to adding cheese after baking. Whether ordered for a family dinner, a gathering with friends or a quick meal, this Italian-American favorite has become part of everyday life throughout the area. The Best of the Best Reader's Choice Awards recognizes establishments that contribute to the region's dining culture, including businesses that have helped shape local tastes for generations.

Downtown Pizza

Downtown Pizza operates in Mingo Junction, Ohio.

DiCarlo's Original Pizza - Multiple Locations

DiCarlo's Original Pizza is closely associated with the Ohio Valley's distinctive style of square-cut pizza. The regional tradition features a rectangular crust baked with tomato sauce, followed by cheese added after the pizza comes out of the oven. This preparation distinguishes Ohio Valley-style pizza from conventional pies that bake the sauce and cheese together. DiCarlo's has helped establish the style as a recognizable part of the region's food culture, with multiple locations serving customers who appreciate its characteristic combination of warm crust, sauce and freshly added cheese.

Mario DiCarlo's Pizza

Mario DiCarlo's Pizza operates in Weirton, West Virginia.

7 Ranges Entertainment

7 Ranges Entertainment combines dining with recreational attractions in Steubenville, Ohio. Its full-service restaurant, The G.O.A.T. House Bar & Grill, offers flatbread among its food selections, including a pepperoni flatbread featured in its weekday lunch specials. The broader menu includes stacked burgers, the Twisted Chicken sandwich, Jenga fries and fried cheese balls.

DeFelice Bros Pizza

DeFelice Bros Pizza serves Follansbee, West Virginia, with a selection of traditional and specialty pizzas. Its build-your-own pies feature a blend of provolone and mozzarella cheeses, with choices of crust, sauce and toppings. Specialty combinations include the DeFelice Special with pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions and mushrooms, along with Mighty Meat, Taco and Hang Ten Hawaiian varieties. White pizzas offer additional choices, including Mediterranean with spinach, Kalamata olives and feta and Spinach Ricotta with multiple cheeses. The restaurant also prepares Detroit-style rectangular pizzas, calzones, pepperoni rolls, sandwiches and pasta dinners.

– Created or enhanced with ChatGPT