The 5 Best Pizzas Around Steubenville

The Ohio Valley is home to a rich and unique pizza tradition, and the community has spoken! These five pizzerias have been named the Best of the Best Reader's Choice Awards 2025 winners, representing the area's favorite interpretations of classic and specialty pies.

Downtown Pizza

Downtown Pizza and Grill is a local favorite celebrated for its diverse menu that includes both classic Italian dishes and unique, flavorful specialty pizzas. The community raves about their quality ingredients and traditional recipes. Notable favorites that get high praise include their incredible Buffalo Chicken Pizza and a delectable Primavera White Pizza (with broccoli, tomato, garlic, and ricotta). Downtown Pizza is your destination for a high-quality, gourmet twist on traditional pizza favorites.

DiCarlo's Original Pizza - Multiple Locations

DiCarlo's is the undisputed patriarch of pizza in the Ohio Valley. Established in 1945, they are credited with inventing the famous Ohio Valley-style pizza (also known as Steubenville-style). This distinct style features a square, crunchy crust with savory tomato sauce that is baked, and then the shredded Provolone cheese and toppings are added cold after it comes out of the oven. The residual heat from the crust partially melts the cheese, creating a uniquely satisfying texture and flavor. This style is an essential part of the local food culture and a must-try.

Mario DiCarlo's Pizza

A highly regarded extension of the DiCarlo's tradition, Mario DiCarlo's Pizza in Weirton is celebrated for its distinctive take on the traditional Ohio Valley pizza. Customers consistently praise the thin, crisp crust and the generous, high-quality toppings. In addition to the famous square-cut slices, this location is also known for its classic round Pizza Bianco (white pizza) and other Italian comfort foods like calzones and stuffed banana peppers.

Bruno's Pizza - Multiple Locations

Bruno's Pizza is a Steubenville staple known for its consistently delicious, high-quality product and family ownership. While incorporating elements of the local Ohio Valley style with a great melting cheese, Bruno's is often noted for a medium-thickness crust that is sometimes compared to a slightly crispier, richer take on a traditional New York-style base. Their success is attributed to four key factors: the crust, the rich homemade sauce, the hearty brick-style cheese, and the over 60 years of family passion poured into every pie.

Jax Pizza

Jax Pizza has garnered a devoted following for its focus on a great dough and quality toppings. Customers rave about their delicious, doughy crust (a thickness that is just right) and the generous amount of quality ingredients. Jax offers a variety of specialty pizzas, including popular options like the BBQ Chicken and Chicken Bacon Ranch. If you're looking for a highly-rated, family-run spot known for a perfectly crafted dough and satisfying slices, Jax Pizza is the community's pick in Richmond.

Thanks, Gemini.