The 5 Best Real Estate Agencies Around Steubenville

Ready to make your move in the competitive Tri-State real estate market? Whether you're searching for your dream home in Steubenville or listing a commercial property in Weirton, choosing the right agency makes all the difference. We've compiled the definitive list of the Best of the Best 2025 Reader’s Choice Awards winners. These five top-tier firms have earned their spots as the most trusted partners for navigating the Ohio Valley's vibrant and fast-moving housing landscape.

JJ Guida Airport Realty

JJ Guida Airport Realty has been a leader in the Tri-State Real Estate Sales market since its inception in 1964. Serving both West Virginia and Ohio, the agency offers expertise in both residential and commercial sales. The company prides itself on providing comprehensive service and has a sister office in Burgettstown, PA, giving its listings double exposure across the WV and PA marketplaces.

Cedar One Realty

Cedar One Realty is a full-service brokerage and property management company in the Ohio Valley. Originally founded in 2004 as a rental property business, it has grown to offer services for buying, selling, and managing residential and commercial properties. They specialize in serving real estate investors, providing professional property management and guidance for both rental and "flip" properties. The company also emphasizes community involvement, hosting local events and supporting local agencies.

Sellitti Realty

Sellitti Realty is an agency known for offering dedicated service to clients in the Ohio Valley. The firm handles transactions for buyers, sellers, renters, and investors. As a local independent brokerage, Sellitti Realty focuses on providing a personalized approach to real estate transactions, ensuring a smooth process whether you are listing a home or searching for a new property in the Weirton and surrounding areas.

Gary W Cain Realtors

Gary W Cain Realtors has a deep history in the Steubenville area, with a legacy spanning decades. The firm operates as Gary W. Cain Realty & Auctioneers, LLC, offering a unique dual service of traditional real estate brokerage along with professional auctioneer services. Their long-standing presence and extensive experience in the local market make them a trusted resource for buying, selling, and appraising properties in Jefferson County and beyond.

Howard Hanna

Howard Hanna (Mortimer Realty) is the local office of the largest privately-owned real estate company in the country. The Weirton office serves the entire Tri-State region, including Steubenville and the greater Pittsburgh area. Howard Hanna is known for offering a full range of home services, seamlessly covering all aspects of a transaction, including buying and selling, mortgage services, title and insurance, and relocation services. Furthermore, they are recognized for innovative programs like their 100% Money Back Guarantee, which aims to provide sellers with confidence and buyers with peace of mind.

Thanks, Gemini.