Our Best of the Best 2025 Reader’s Choice Awards highlight the top five destinations for outstanding salads in the Tri-State area. These winners are celebrated for their commitment to fresh ingredients, house-made dressings, generous portions, and inventive recipes—from hearty steak salads to classic Greek preparations.
The Ville has been a Steubenville favorite since 1996, earning accolades for its commitment to fresh, homemade American and Italian fare. Their famous salads are built on a foundation of quality ingredients and signature dressings, including their creamy homemade ranch, bold homemade blue cheese, and house Italian. Diners frequently praise the large portion sizes and the option to add premium proteins.
While renowned for their award-winning steaks, Abdalla's is also a local legend for its incredible salads, often featuring their famous house dressing. Customers rave about their hearty Steak Salad and Chicken Salad, which are generously layered with fresh-cut fries and Provolone cheese, making them a full, satisfying meal along the Ohio River.
Theo Yianni's brings a taste of authentic Mediterranean cuisine to the area. This cozy Greek restaurant is celebrated for its fresh, vibrant Greek Salad, often cited as a must-try. Their menu focuses on traditional flavors, offering salads that are well-balanced and feature high-quality ingredients like olives, feta, and perfectly seasoned meats.
A long-standing Italian institution, Mario's is cherished for its homemade cuisine, and that same quality extends to its salads. Popular choices include their Antipasto Salad and house-made Tossed Salad, which often feature fresh ingredients, various meats, cheeses, and their signature Italian dressings, complementing their delicious pizzas and pasta dishes.
Known primarily for its wings, Wing It has also secured a place on this list with its unexpectedly excellent Grilled Chicken Salad. This spot provides a great option for a lighter meal, offering fresh greens and quality grilled chicken, perfect for those looking for a satisfying, non-fried alternative alongside their favorite wing flavors.
Thanks, Gemini.