The 5 Best Steaks Around Steubenville

Ready for a truly satisfying meal? The Steubenville community has voted! These five top-rated restaurants were voted the best in the area in the Best of the Best Reader's Choice Awards 2025 for serving up incredible, mouth-watering steaks and memorable dining experiences.

Abdalla's Tavern And Grill

A true local legend, Abdalla's Tavern And Grill (106 1st Ave, Stratton, OH 43961) is famous for its New York Strip Steak Dinner, often smothered in grilled onions and sautéed mushrooms and served with their signature buttered JoJo Potatoes. This establishment has reportedly been winning the "Best Steak" Reader's Choice Award for 14 straight years, confirming its status as a must-try classic for charcoal-broiled perfection.

Texas Roadhouse

Texas Roadhouse (100 Mall Dr, Steubenville, OH 43952) is the go-to spot for a wide variety of legendary, hand-cut steaks grilled to order. Diners enjoy favorites like the lean and juicy Dallas Filet, the flavorful Ft. Worth Ribeye, and the large, marbled Bone-In Ribeye. They also offer popular steak combos and their famous Road Kill chop steak, ensuring a classic American steakhouse experience.

White Bear

White Bear (9229 OH-43, Bloomingdale, OH 43910) is cherished as a local classic known for its great food and inviting atmosphere. While their full menu features a range of popular dishes, the community relies on White Bear for exceptional quality and homestyle cooking. Be sure to check with them directly for their daily specials and recognized steak or meat-focused entrees that earned them a spot on this list.

Bistro 303 Prime Cuisine

For a higher-end experience, Bistro 303 Prime Cuisine (303 Three Springs Drive, Weirton, WV 26062) delivers a sophisticated dining environment focused on premium cuts. Their Chef's Prime Selection includes an 8 oz Filet Mignon, a generous 14 oz Certified Prime Angus New York Strip, and the impressive 20 oz USDA Prime bone-in Cowboy Steak. This is the place for those seeking the ultimate prime steak and surf & turf experience.

Pastaio Cucina Rustica Italiana

Pastaio Cucina Rustica Italiana (725 Main St, Wintersville, OH 43953) earns its place not just for Italian fare, but for an incredible overall dining experience that includes expertly prepared meat dishes and specials. While known primarily for its fresh, homemade pasta, their commitment to traditional Italian cuisine often includes savory, rustic preparations of meat that were recognized in the voting. Visit for an elevated, authentic Italian dining experience.

Thanks, Gemini