The 5 Best Subs Around Steubenville

Ready for the perfect sandwich? The Steubenville community has spoken! These five top-rated spots were voted the best in the area in the Best of the Best Reader's Choice Awards 2025 for serving up incredible, loaded subs and hoagies.

Federico Foods

A true Steubenville institution for over 90 years, Federico Foods (3911 Sunset Blvd, Steubenville, OH 43952) is famous for its authentic Italian Hoagies. These subs are crafted daily using high-quality imported Italian meats and cheeses, all served on their signature, freshly baked bread and buns. It’s the essential stop for a classic, traditional Italian deli sandwich experience.

Def Louie's Sandwich Shop

Known for hand-crafted quality and creative names, Def Louie's Sandwich Shop (2198 Sunset Blvd, Steubenville, OH 43952) is a local favorite. Diners flock here for specialties like The Fratelli (Ham, Soppressata, Capicola, Provolone) and the hearty The Gooey Lewis (Roast beef, Swiss, Provolone served with hot au jus for dipping). They were recognized as a 2024 Finalist for Best Subs, confirming their popularity for delicious, generously-loaded sandwiches.

Jimmy John's

The reliable choice for speed and consistency, Jimmy John's (225 Franciscan Square, Steubenville, OH 43952) provides "Freaky Fast" sandwiches. Popular options include the Vito (Italian-style sub with capicola, Genoa salami, and provolone) and the Turkey Tom. It’s the ideal spot for fresh ingredients, precise assembly, and quick delivery or pickup, making it a dependable choice for lunch.

Natalie’s Nook

A beloved local gem across the river, Natalie’s Nook (1610 Pennsylvania Ave., Weirton, WV 26062) is cherished for its commitment to great food and homestyle flavor. While they offer a variety of popular dishes, the community recognizes Natalie's for its exceptional quality and hearty, satisfying subs and sandwiches that earned them a spot on this list. Be sure to check with them directly for their daily offerings.

Subway - Multiple Locations

As a nationwide favorite with locations throughout the Weirton/Steubenville area, Subway - Multiple Locations (Weirton, WV) remains a strong contender, recognized for its fully customizable subs. Diners appreciate the ability to choose their bread, fillings, and toppings, including classics like the Meatball Marinara and the Spicy Italian, ensuring a sandwich tailored exactly to taste.

Thanks, Gemini.