The 5 Best Tax Return Preparers Around Steubenville

The community has voted on the top spots for financial services! These five professional firms and services were selected as the Best of the Best in the Steubenville area in the Reader's Choice Awards 2025.s

Albert F. Macre & Co., CPAs

Established in 1991, Albert F. Macre & Co., CPAs is a full-service Certified Public Accountant (CPA) firm that excels in accounting, comprehensive tax services, and management advisory. Their major strength for business owners is the seamless integration with Payroll+ Services, offering a complete, low-cost solution for both tax preparation and integrated payroll management, all from one trusted local source. This streamlined approach ensures consistency and efficiency for local enterprises.

D'Anniballe & Company, Inc.

Serving the Tri-State area since 1949, D'Anniballe & Company, Inc. offers clients the advantage of over 70 years of comprehensive financial experience. Beyond standard individual and business tax preparation, they specialize in complex financial and estate matters, including litigation support, estate planning, and compiled/reviewed financial statement services. This depth of expertise makes them the ideal choice for individuals and businesses with complicated financial histories or unique planning needs.

Sherrin & Associates, CPA

Sherrin & Associates, CPA is a family-owned accounting firm that has been serving the Ohio Valley for over 50 years, providing clients with a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere. Their defining strength lies in their specialized tax expertise; they are particularly noted as experts in handling oil and gas royalties for the region, in addition to managing corporate, partnership, and individual income tax returns. They also provide essential supporting services like monthly accounting and payroll.

Puskarich Accounting & Tax, LLC

Puskarich Accounting & Tax, LLC is a highly focused local firm dedicated to providing professional accounting and tax services primarily to the Follansbee and Weirton communities across the river in West Virginia. The key benefit is the personalized attention and deep familiarity with the local economy, ensuring expert tax advice and filing services tailored to the specific needs of residents and small businesses in the immediate vicinity.

H&R Block - Multiple Locations

As a major national provider, H&R Block offers the distinct advantage of maximum refund and 100% accuracy guarantees, supported by a vast network of trained professionals, including CPAs and Enrolled Agents. They provide ultimate flexibility with virtual, drop-off, and in-office tax preparation options, making them highly accessible for quick or complex tax needs. They also offer specialized small business services like ITIN applications and bookkeeping.

Thanks, Gemini.