The 5 Best Thrift/Consignment Stores Around Steubenville

The thrill of finding a one-of-a-kind item, the satisfaction of supporting a good cause, and the benefit of embracing sustainable shopping—these are just a few reasons why thrifting has become a favorite pastime in the Steubenville area. Our community’s collection of thrift and consignment shops goes far beyond just clothes; they are hubs for vintage furniture, antique treasures, and locally crafted gifts. These stores not only offer affordable alternatives to buying new but also actively contribute to the local economy and various charitable missions, promoting a circular economy where every item gets a second chance.

The community has spoken! These five exceptional establishments were selected as the Best of the Best in the Steubenville area in the Reader's Choice Awards 2025 for their unique inventory, commitment to mission, and great value. Whether you're hunting for a budget-friendly wardrobe upgrade or a rare piece of local history, these are the places you need to visit.

St. Vincent De Paul Society Thrift Store

This location operates as part of the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, a Catholic lay organization dedicated to helping neighbors in need. The defining strength of shopping here is the direct, charitable impact your purchase makes. All store profits are used to fund the organization's extensive mission work, which includes providing financial aid, food, clothing, and household goods to struggling families through their voucher programs. By thrifting here, you're investing directly into the community's well-being.

Moe's On Main

Moe's on Main operates as a consignment craft and gift store. The primary advantage of visiting this shop is its specialty in affordable custom and personalized gifts, making it the perfect spot to find a one-of-a-kind, thoughtful item. Beyond consignment goods, they foster community engagement by regularly hosting craft classes, allowing patrons to learn new skills while supporting local artisans and keeping resources within the Follansbee community.

Urban Mission

The Urban Mission is a central force in community development, and its thrift operations support its wider scope of work. Shopping at the Mission's stores gives you the benefit of supporting a large-scale organization that offers a diversity of essential programs, including food and spiritual care, workforce development, and emergency assistance. This holistic approach means your consumer dollars fuel multiple facets of community empowerment in the Steubenville area.

Two Antique Geeks

This family and veteran-owned small business is dedicated to specializing in high-quality antiques, retro, vintage, and primitive items. The key benefit of this store is the carefully curated and fun, relaxed shopping experience they provide. They pride themselves on ensuring all items are clean and well-displayed, creating an atmosphere that encourages sharing memories and finding genuine treasures from the past, rather than just rummaging through clutter.

Urban Thrift & Opportunity Center

More than just a thrift shop, this is an Opportunity Center and the dedicated retail arm of the Urban Mission. The unique benefit here is that your patronage directly funds and serves as a work site for the Urban Mission Works employment readiness and mentoring program. This initiative provides job training in customer service, retail management, and more for individuals facing barriers to employment, effectively creating a cyclical economy where secondhand goods lead to fresh starts and new career opportunities.

Thanks, Gemini.